In the meantime, businesses are attempting to operate normally, albeit remotely and with reduced staffing, with many businesses up and down the country furloughing staff under the Government’s Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme. It is also true to say that our relationship with, and perception of the physical office space has changed in recent weeks, potentially influencing future real estate decisions materially. However, in the short term, what will be the appetite for office space when ‘normality’ resumes?
What does historical data tell us?
A property researcher’s first port of call is to seek out comparisons. The financial crisis in 2008 is our most recent reference point for economic upheaval on a global scale. The demand for office space declined as the crisis took hold. Leasing activity in the UK’s largest office market of central London fell by 21% in 2009. This followed a 19% reduction in space let in 2008. The economic shock quite clearly had an impact on office space demand. Many occupiers put expansion plans on hold, some reduced their headcount, and many businesses shut altogether. However, businesses did adapt and when positive economic indicators returned, so did the appetite for new workspace. Leasing activity rebounded in 2010 wholeheartedly.
Another recent reference point is the 2016 EU Brexit referendum. The UK’s decision to leave the European Union (EU) caused political and economic shockwaves. Stock and currency markets reacted quickly and tumbled. Uncertainty set in, causing leasing of office space across London to slow down. However, this was short-lived, with office demand picking up in the final quarter of 2016, cushioning the impact of the summer slowdown. Despite the end of year rally, total office space leased in 2016 across London fell by 24% on the previous year. This was largely due to uncertainty – ebbing and flowing over three years – as a result of the uncertain outcome of Brexit and whether we would indeed leave. However, businesses could not and can not defer real estate decisions forever, or until there was absolute clarity on the outcome of Brexit, causing demand in 2018-19 to peak.
Uncertainty stemming from the COVID-19 pandemic, however, is different. Today’s crisis is not just economic or political; it is a medical and social emergency. There is no recent historical precedent to compare to. Even recent virus scares such as SARS, MERS, Swine Flu or Ebola did not lead to measures of the scale being taken today. When the virus does dissipate, businesses will quickly want to resume to ‘normality,’ as seen in previous crises. Definitive timing of when this will happen is of course as yet unknown.
Recession
The duration of ‘lockdown’ will be one of the key determining factors when we consider the impact that this virus will have on businesses and the wider economy. The UK will likely enter a recession as a result of the disruption. The Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) has released a stark scenario analysis suggesting that the UK could lose up to 35% of its GDP in the second quarter of this year, with unemployment rising by 2 million people to 10% of the working population. Other western economies are bracing themselves for similar scenarios, with the International Monetary Fund already dubbing it the ‘Great Lockdown Depression’, rivalling that of the Great Depression of the 1920s. In line with a number of economists however, the OBR predicts that the downturn is likely to be for a shorter period than expected. Business and consumer eagerness to move on could see a release of pent-up spending and investment, providing a boost to the economy and putting it on a fast-track recovery.
Demand
Following three weeks of social distancing measures, the office market had been effectively put on ice. Given that the lockdown occurred at the end of Q1, data on market fundamentals do not reveal a huge impact as yet. Our research shows that office availability across the UK’s largest market of central London increased by a marginal 2% at the end of March 2020, compared with the level at the beginning of the year. Rental prices have remained at similar levels. For the moment, it is unlikely that the majority of landlords will consider reduced rents, at least outside of the well-documented deferrals and abatements being discussed whilst we remain under lockdown. They are more likely to enter into conversations about improved incentive packages or even deferring lease start dates until the time is right. However, we do expect that Q2 will be a different picture, with a dip in demand as businesses adjust to current working practices and the full force of lockdown is displayed in market data.
Yet office space demand is likely to resume and rebound. Between June 2020 and December 2021, there are approximately 1,500 tenants in over 10 million sq ft of office space across central London with leases due to expire. Whilst much of this space will be renewed for ease of continuity during the recovery phase, others will surely grasp the opportunity to reassess their footprint. This could be in the size, location, or the way in which space is leased (more flexible terms).
The government is providing most businesses with economic support measures to weather the storm and to enable them to come out fighting on the other side. We believe that further measures are necessary, however, such as an extension of the business rates holiday to include all sectors, to ensure no business is left behind. We may experience a short-sharp-shock, yet hope that the recovery will be just as quick and equally strong. Yet the market for tenants is likely to be quite different. Just a few weeks ago, I was writing about a squeeze on the choice of available space, rising rents and the lack of immediate Grade A space. With one global event, we are potentially likely to see the exact opposite of this, as businesses and the real estate industry adjusts. The adjustments that may not be visible just yet, but like the coronavirus, they will have a long-lasting impact.
The UK commercial real estate market has previously proved robust to shocks – we believe it will be so again. We will be closely following every eventuality, measure from government, and supply and demand movements.
As experts in commercial property leasing and workplace design, we have much advice we can offer on how you might choose to adapt, overcome, and hopefully even prosper from the changes that this crisis will compel so many of us to make – the most adventurous and entrepreneurial businesses will relish the platform to do just this. Let us know what factors you are considering with regard to your space, premises, culture and adjustments, and if we can help you take stock, either in an advisory capacity or assist you in your workplace journey, please get in touch.
